Warner Chilcott Letter - 340B Pricing
Errors
September
05, 2008
Jimmy Mitchell, R.Ph., M.P.F., M.S.
Director
Office of Pharmacy Affairs
Health Resources and Services Administration
Department of Health and Human Services
5600 Fishers Lane, Parklawn Building
Mail Stop 10C-03
Rockville, Maryland 20857
Dear Mr. Mitchell,
I write to confirm our previous discussions
regarding prices charged to 340B covered
entities for certain Warner Chilcott products
during the time period from the first
quarter of 2005 through the first quarter
of 2008. As we have explained, a review
of our government pricing programs, conducted
as a part of Warner Chilcott's routine
compliance procedures, revealed pricing
errors with respect to certain of our
products subject to discounts under Section
340B of the Public Health Service Act
and our Pharmaceutical Pricing Agreement
("PPA") with the Secretary of
the Department of Health and Human Services.
Warner Chilcott's review revealed that
the 340B ceiling prices on a number of
Warner Chilcott products, (see list of
affected products at Attachment
A to this letter), were calculated
inaccurately. The ceiling prices for 340B
entities were calculated as Average Manufacturer
Price reduced by the statutory minimum
rebate percentage (15.1%) without making
applicable adjustments to the formula
for price increases in excess of CPI-U,
as required by the provisions of 42 U.S.C.
§§ 256(a)(2) and 1396r-8(c)(2)(A).
This error in calculation for the 340B
entities resulted in some products being
priced higher than permitted under the
PPA. The calculation error did not impact
Medicaid or Veteran Affairs/Federal Supply
Schedule pricing. As soon as Warner Chilcott
discovered these pricing errors, we promptly
undertook to identify their scope and
to correct the problem. We have verified
that all 340B pricing calculations done
after the first quarter of 2008 are accurate.
In order to ensure that a similar error
does not happen again, Warner Chilcott
is monitoring these calculations going
forward, and has strengthened the controls,
including monitoring controls, and documentation
surrounding the government pricing process.
We have conducted a recalculation of affected
340B ceiling prices and purchase prices
for the first quarter of 2005 through
the first quarter of 2008, and determined
that the total refunds due to 340B covered
entities for all products purchased during
that recalculation period, established
consistent with the record maintenance
requirement at Section II(d) of the PPA,
is approximately $3 million. We are preparing
letters to each of the affected 340B entities,
detailing the purchase volume and price
differential of each Warner Chilcott product
that our records reflect the entity purchased
at a price above the applicable 340B ceiling.
The letters will also include a refund
check in the appropriate amount and an
acknowledgement and release form that
the entity will be requested to complete
and return to Warner Chilcott.
Warner Chilcott will monitor these disbursements
and use its best efforts to ensure that
all entitled entities receive their refunds
in a timely fashion. We anticipate that
we will be able to transmit letters and
checks to affected covered entities within
approximately the next three months. Any
covered entity that purchased any of the
products listed in Attachment A under
the 340B program that has questions regarding
the refund it receives or that does not
receive a letter and refund check by December
15, 2008, should contact Jim Black
(973-442-3200) at Warner Chilcott.
As we have discussed, Warner Chilcott
consents to the posting of this letter
on the Office of Pharmacy Affairs' website
to help inform 340B covered entities.
If you have any questions relating to
this letter or the process we have established,
or if you need any additional information,
please do not hesitate to contact me.
| Very truly yours,
/Susanna J. Gray/
Assistant General Counsel
Warner
Chilcott |
Encl.
cc: Mary Riordan (via Federal
Express and electronic mail, with encl.)
Deirdre
Duzor (via Federal Express and electronic
mail, with encl.)
Attachment A
| LBLR |
Core |
Size |
Description |
| 430 |
112 |
24 |
Doryx 100 100 D-R Tabs |
| 430 |
838 |
19 |
Doryx 100MG 100's |
| 430 |
836 |
20 |
Doryx 75 60 |
| 430 |
111 |
20 |
Doryx 75 60 D-R Tabs |
| 72 |
260 |
12 |
Dovonex Cream 120G Tube |
| 430 |
3020 |
17 |
Dovonex Cream 120G Tube |
| 72 |
260 |
6 |
Dovonex Cream 60G Tube |
| 430 |
3020 |
15 |
Dovonex Cream 60G Tube |
| 72 |
2540 |
6 |
Dovonex Oint 60G |
| 430 |
3010 |
15 |
Dovonex Oint 60G |
| 72 |
2540 |
12 |
Dovonex Oint 120G Tube |
| 430 |
3010 |
17 |
Dovonex Oint 120G Tube |
| 72 |
1160 |
6 |
Dovonex Sol 60ML BTL |
| 430 |
3030 |
15 |
Dovonex Sol 60ML BTL |
| 87 |
782 |
41 |
Duricef 250MG/5ML 100ML |
| 87 |
782 |
42 |
Duricef 250MLG/5ML 50ML |
| 87 |
783 |
5 |
Duricef 500MG/5ML 75ML |
| 87 |
783 |
41 |
Duricef 500MG/5ML 100ML |
| 87 |
784 |
46 |
Duricef 500MG 50's CAPS |
| 87 |
784 |
48 |
Duricef 500MG 50's CAPS |
| 430 |
780 |
19 |
Duricef 500MG 50's CAPS |
| 430 |
2782 |
15 |
Duricef 250MG/5ML 50ML |
| 430 |
2782 |
17 |
Duricef 250MG/5ML 100ML |
| 430 |
2783 |
16 |
Duricef 500MG/5ML 750ML |
| 430 |
2783 |
17 |
Duricef O/S |
| 430 |
696 |
24 |
Eryc |
| 430 |
570 |
14 |
Estrostep FE 5 X 28S |
| 430 |
696 |
24 |
Eryc |
| 430 |
482 |
14 |
Femcon FE 35 28x5 |
| 430 |
145 |
14 |
Femhrt 0.5/25mcg 28x5 |
| 430 |
145 |
23 |
Femhrt 0.5/25mcg 90's |
| 430 |
544 |
14 |
Femhrt 28 X 5 |
| 430 |
544 |
23 |
Femhrt Bottle |
| 430 |
6201 |
40 |
Femring 0.05 MG/Day |
| 430 |
6202 |
40 |
Femring 0.1 Strength |
| 430 |
389 |
24 |
Femtrace .45 ** |
| 430 |
390 |
24 |
Femtrace .9 ** |
| 430 |
391 |
24 |
Femtrace 1.8 ** |
| 430 |
530 |
14 |
Loestrin 24 FE |
| 430 |
227 |
23 |
Natachew |
| 430 |
226 |
40 |
Natafort Prenatal Tabs |
| 430 |
582 |
14 |
Ovcon 35 |
| 430 |
580 |
14 |
Ovcon 35 - 28 Day |
| 430 |
581 |
14 |
Ovcon 35 FE CHEW |
| 430 |
585 |
14 |
Ovcon 50 |
| 430 |
182 |
15 |
Pyridium Plus 150/15 30's |
| 430 |
435 |
14 |
Sarafem 10 28 |
| 430 |
436 |
14 |
Sarafem 20 28 |
| 430 |
3230 |
15 |
Taclonex |
| 430 |
3230 |
16 |
Taclonex |
|